Nostalgic – Page 4 – The Candy Cottage

ATTENTION - WE WILL NOT BE SHIPPING ORDERS FROM JULY 25-AUGUST 2, 2025. PLEASE BE AWARE BEFORE PLACING AN ORDER DURING THIS TIME. SHIPPING WILL RESUME ON MONDAY, AUGUST 4TH.

Welcome to our store

**Shipping during hot weather may result in melted candy. Melting is not a damage claim. Please be aware of temperatures prior to placing an order.

Welcome to our store

Cinna-Pix Cinnamon Toothpicks

Cinna-Pix Cinnamon Toothpicks

Regular price $2.59 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.59 USD
Unit price per
PEZ Candy Refills

PEZ Candy Refills

Regular price $2.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.99 USD
Unit price per
Milk Duds

Milk Duds

Regular price $2.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.99 USD
Unit price per
Sugar Daddy Mini Lollipops

Sugar Daddy Mini Lollipops

Regular price $0.69 USD

Regular price Sale price $0.69 USD
Unit price per
Rock Candy Crystals

Rock Candy Crystals

Regular price $2.59 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.59 USD
Unit price per
Original Peanut Chews

Sold out

Original Peanut Chews

Regular price $2.89 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.89 USD
Unit price per

Sold out
Million Dollar Chocolate Bar

Million Dollar Chocolate Bar

Regular price $2.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.49 USD
Unit price per
Cinnamon Toothpicks

Cinnamon Toothpicks

Regular price $1.99 USD

Regular price Sale price $1.99 USD
Unit price per
Twizzlers Hershey Chocolate Twists

Twizzlers Hershey Chocolate Twists

Regular price $4.29 USD

Regular price Sale price $4.29 USD
Unit price per
Turkish Taffy

Turkish Taffy

Regular price $2.29 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.29 USD
Unit price per
Sweetarts

Sweetarts

Regular price $2.39 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.39 USD
Unit price per
Sugar Daddy

Sold out

Sugar Daddy

Regular price $2.49 USD

Regular price Sale price $2.49 USD
Unit price per

Sold out